[中图分类号]D922.284[文献标识码]A[文章编号]1004-3306(2024)02-0071-10 DOI:10.13497/j.cnki.is.2024.02.006
资源价格:30积分
[摘 要]作为商业健康保险中最常见的条款之一,既往症条款产生了较告知义务规则更为严苛的效果,受到了国内理论研究、司法裁判和监管态度上的较多否定。但现有观点以及比较法上的讨论均无法完全反驳关于既往症条款“保障范围”“客观主义”等性质定位,也引起了对保前症状的解释方式争议。追溯适用历史可以发现,起源于团体保险的既往症条款最初系通过确定保障范围实现“尽量接纳成员”的目的,但在适用于个人保险后产生了向“防范逆向选择”的变迁。在适用告知义务规则判断既往症条款效力时,应基于《民法典》对违反强制性规范法律行为效力的理论发展,在目的比较下对团体保险和个人保险中的既往症条款作出不同评价,并对保前症状的解释适用不同标准。
[关键词]既往症条款;告知义务规则;相对强制性规范;团体保险;目的比较
[作者简介]王家骏,中国政法大学博士后研究人员,研究方向:保险法、侵权法。
The Validity of the Pre-existing Condition Clause under the Obligation of Disclosure of the Insurance Law
WANG Jia-jun
Abstract:As one of the most common clauses in commercial health insurance,the pre-existing condition clause has a more stringent effect on the disclosure obligation rule,thus it is widely criticized by the judicial and theoretical societies and regulatory bodies.However,current opinions and comparative law-based discussions cannot completely disprove the pre-existing condition′s provisions on “scope of coverage” and “objectivism”.This has also given rise to the controversy over the interpretation of the pre-existing condition clause.Tracing back the history of this clause′s application,we can see that it first originated in group insurance,aiming to realize the goal of “accepting membership to the largest extent”.However,when it was applied to individual insurance,this clause shifted to “prevent against adverse selection”.When judging on the validity of the pre-existing condition clause when the rule of disclosure obligation is applied,we should follow the Civil Code′s theoretical development on the validity of legal actions which violate mandatory regulations.Moreover,we should make differentiated assessment on the pre-existing condition clause for group insurance and individual insurance with the comparison of their different purposes,and apply different standards to the interpretation of pre-existing conditions.
Key words:pre-existing condition clause;duty of disclosure;relative mandatory rules;group insurance;objective comparison
《保险研究》20240301-《政策性农业保险的理论演进——兼论中国农业保险研究进展》(易福金、燕菲儿、杨柳)
《保险研究》20240302-《负面信息如何影响农户对保险公司的信任》(张跃华、阎文溯、Calum G.Turvey)
《保险研究》20240303-《专利保险试点政策与企业数字化转型》(向海凌、陈佳盈、吴非)
《保险研究》20240304-《美国投资型保险的监管历史及其逻辑》(李敏)
《保险研究》20240305-《大病风险教育与个体重疾险购买决策》(李天一、刘璐、王正位、沈鹏)
《保险研究》20240306-《挤入还是挤出:基本医疗卫生服务影响商业健康险消费效应分析》(邢晓卫、匡贤明)